Texas Court Dumps Woman's Death Sentence
By MICHAEL GRACZYK
Associated Press Writer
May 23, 2007, 1:26 PM EDT
HOUSTON -- A sharply divided appeals court on Wednesday threw out the death sentence of a woman convicted of killing her newborn son.
The court upheld the woman's conviction, but it said prosecutors misstated to jurors her likelihood of being a future danger to society before deliberations began on the sentence.
Lawyers for the woman, Kenisha Berry, argued that she had no previous criminal record, and defense experts testified that she posed a low risk of being a future danger.
The 5-4 ruling from the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals means Berry will serve a life term for the 1998 smothering death of 4-day-old Malachi, who was found abandoned and bound with duct tape in a trash bin.
The case went unsolved for five years until Berry was identified as the mother of a newborn girl found alive but abandoned and covered with fire ants in a ditch in 2003.
Berry, a former corrections officer and day care worker, consented to DNA testing that confirmed she also was the mother of the boy.
A jury in Beaumont convicted Berry of murder and sentenced her to death.
In a written dissent to Wednesday's ruling overturning that sentence, four appeals judges said they would have upheld the death penalty for Berry and suggested the majority argument could exempt from the death penalty most parents who kill their children.
"She cold-heartedly murdered one child and attempted to murder another child on different occasions five years later," Judge Barbara Hervey wrote in the dissent. "She is unremorseful and fails to take responsibility. This evidence satisfied every measure of future-dangerousness that this court has applied."
Berry has three other children who were not harmed.
She was one of 10 women on Texas' death row.
Copyright 2007 Newsday Inc.
Brenda Andrew is the only woman on Oklahoma death row. She is there for the murder of her husband by her and her boyfriend James Pav...
Morgan Smith. Wow. Just, wow. She came from a family of mental illnesses with a father who committed suicide. She had spent her life on ...
Ezra McCandless Stabs Bf 16 Times Pleads Not Guilt Every few months or so I run up on a case that gets a lot of local attention. I'v...